What's The Value of Your Reputation?
If you have high quality support services and polices, and your employee satisfaction surveys show that your employees are happy, does that mean your customers actually experience results that match or exceed your brand promise? Is the culture of your employee base consistent with the values of your company? Are different employee groups delivering quite different experiences to your customers, like sales and service appearing to speak a different language? These inconsistencies create disjointed experiences for customers who will be constantly adjusting to your company’s different styles, behaviors, standards of performance, and promises. This makes it very difficult to develop a sense of affinity and loyalty with your company. The Service-Profit Chain developed by Heskett, Sasser and Schlesinger (1997) from Harvard Business School establishes relationships between profitability, customer loyalty, and employee satisfaction, loyalty, and productivity. This model suggests that profit and growth are stimulated primarily by customer loyalty, which is a direct result of customer satisfaction. Satisfaction is greatly influenced by the value of service provided to customers. Satisfied, loyal, and productive employees create value. Employee satisfaction, in turn, results primarily from high quality support services and policies that enable employees to deliver results to customers. While the Service-Profit Chain model provides an essential foundation to assure that your employees are delivering results to customers, a focus simply on employee support services and policies will not result in employees delighting the customer and delivering on your brand promise. You need a defined employee culture, and reward and recognition system that aligns behaviors consistent with the brand promise of your business. This strong link and consistent behaviors will strengthen the bond of loyalty with your customers, lower the cost of support service, and accelerate operating efficiency and sustained profitability. In financial terms, the value of a brand can be a significant component of the value of the company. The price paid for acquired businesses is frequently substantially higher than the appraised value determined from the tangible assets of the company. According to a study in 1995: "the average market value of all American-based publicly traded companies was 70% greater than their replacement cost (e.g., their tangible net asset value.)" 1 Assessing the actual brand value of a B2B services company should include the customer facing processes to determine how effectively the various functions and people are aligned to deliver performance consistent with the brand promise of the company. Unrealistic prices can be paid for brand value that may be tied to market awareness and market share, rather than any real capability of the company to perform commensurate with its reputation. Brand value should be discounted by elements that fail to deliver effectively, or where significant inconsistencies exist between the company and its customers’ expectations for the future. Consider the case of Philip Morris: "In 1989, Philip Morris paid $12.9 billion for Kraft, six times its net asset value. According to Philip Morris CEO Hamish Maxwell, his company needed a portfolio of brands that had strong brand loyalty [i.e., customer relationships] that could be leveraged to enable the tobacco company to diversify [i.e., financial relationships], especially in the retail food industry [i.e., trade relationships]."2 Philip Morris paid billions for a set of relationships and the expectations that those relationships would enable Philip Morris to conduct business in entirely new ways in the future. In addition to significantly affecting the purchase price of a company, the value of the brand and brand equity directly affects stock price of the company. A Cap Gemini Ernst & Young report issued in 2000 concluded "brand power can account for 5 to 7 percent of the change in a company's stock price." 3 A study of 220 companies identified that corporate brand image could be quantified with the following components: Advertising spending 30%
Size of company 23%
Low dividend 10%
Earnings volatility 7%
Stock price growth 8%
Other factors* 22% *(including marketing components such as events and publicity, industry affiliation, product categories, message quality, etc.)4 Note that 52% of the factors influencing the brand image are those associated with ensuring that your brand message and promise are effectively defined and clearly articulated. This brief analysis shows that effectively developing and executing a comprehensive company-wide brand strategy will contribute significantly to the value of the company. The steps that can be taken to accomplish this are defined and uniquely adaptable to any business. The results will be measured in the increased performance and innovation of every function of the company, leading to improved sustained profitable growth and continuing growth in stock equity. 1, 2 Tom Duncan, Driving Brand Value, pg. 4. 3 "Name Brand Calculus or Imaginary Numbers?" US Banker, Volume 113, Number 6, Page 26, June 2003. 4 Ad Value, Leslie Butterfield, ed., Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, 2003, "How advertising impacts on share price," James Gregory, pgs. 17-25. Patrick Smyth. Business advisor. Serving small and medium businesses in managing change to improve performance. Helping leaders overcome challenges to achieve their goals and reconnect them with their dreams. 615-261-8585 http://www.innovationhabitude.com |
Other Articles
A good logo vs. a FABULOUS logo If you had a choice, which one would you choose, a good logo or a fabulous logo? Think about it for a second here, although I know the answer is crystal clear. Because many of us settle for a good logo created by a credible logo designer just because he or she is a credible logo designer who charges low prices. For example, I had a client who pa ...Is Podcasting a Viable Medium? Today’s Myatt on Mondays question comes from a Chief Marketing Officer of a professional services firm who asks: “Is Podcasting a Viable Medium?” I have answered questions like this each time a new medium comes to market. Over the years I’ve commented on fax machines, infomercials, e-mail, e-mercials, CD-ROM’s and DVD’s, Internet Yellow Pages (I ...A Lesson in Branding from Paris Hilton I have never been a fan of Paris Hilton.I see her parading around in her odd-looking clothing choices, leading her loyal following of giddy anorexic schoolgirls around by their noses, and I think, "Skank."I saw Paris condescend to the working class farmers of America, and I didn't like it at all. So I decided not to watch her show. ...Nonprofit Name Change - Four Tips for Success In April of 2004, the NOW Legal Defense and Education fund changed their name to Legal Momentum. The name change was a grand success. LM's Vice President of Communications, Maureen McFadden, shares these four tips to ensure the same success for your nonprofit:1. Dedicate Yourself. Dedicate yourself to a long-term proce ...Mobile Marketing: Why It Works Mobile marketing is a type of marketing that is done throughout the world. It incorporates the use of the mobile phone to provide information, advertisements and other types of promotion. There is a great wealth of value in this type of product and service simply because of its ability to get right to the customer at the right time. By promot ...Repeat Until Memorized I remember, as a child, raptly watching a Saturday morning adventure TV show where the hero was captured by the “bad guys” who gave him the “Ancient Water Torture” in order to extract secret information. Seems our hero was tied down while an endless amount of water was dropped on his forehead, drop by drop, until he would capitulate and divulge ...McDonalds Supply Chain of Potatoes McDonald's buys its potatoes from corporate farmers in Idaho not the commodities market; therefore it limits its exposure to price gouging that might have occurred by using the commodity exchange to get those potatoes. Starbucks is doing the same thing, but instead of having partnerships and coffee beans, they are all of in-house. Its Starbucks ...Promote Your Business With The Right Logo How important is a logo for the success of your business? Opinions might vary but the importance of a logo can hardly be overlooked. It's a logo that first catches the eyes of the onlookers and lends a concrete identity to a business enterprise. Can anything be more satisfying than popular logo? I guess not!A business or company logo cre ...Will Your Brand Take Root This Spring? - Part 1 Just as it takes a combination of all the right elements to make a beautiful garden grow, it takes more than a great logo, or a great ad to grow a successful business. How do the best businesses do it? They use an integrated approach to their marketing, combining a great visual identity with a compelling message that gets delivered through a var ...Selling Your Own Fragrance Brand Selling your own fragrance is complex, rewarding and profitable. Complex because there are so many items to be considered bottles, labels, packaging, shipping, size and price.Rewarding because there is nothing quite like the buzz of seeing your product in a quality store being bought by a customer. Profitable because if your program is su ...Which Comes First, Branding or Marketing? Let’s see, which came first the chicken or the egg? While the jury is still out on that old story, I recently realized that many entrepreneurs don’t clearly understand the difference between branding and marketing.I’m here to set the record straight once and for all! The findings might surprise you and will forever change the way you loo ...Banner Advertising: News of its Demise is Premature You have seen them all over the internet -- blinking, flashing, animated and garish. You vow that you will not contribute to this internet graffiti. You feel smug with your decision because after all banner advertising is dead.Wrong. Banner advertising is not dead -- and in fact it is still an effective internet marketing tool. However ba ...Branding Junk Removal - He Did It, Can You? What does it mean to be remarkable?Brian Scudamore, CEO and Founder of 1-800-GOT-JUNK?, who in 1996 was operating the million dollar plus company at the age of 26, said it means, “You’ve got to get out there and be loud and proud... You’ve got to stand out. You have got to have a brand that is worth remarking about.”He learned much ...What Makes a Good Logo? One of the most important marketing tools is an effective logo. It provides an easily recognizable identity for your business or organization. It not only communicates who you are but what you are. Therefore, every business or organization contemplating adopting a logo should know the criteria that make for an effective logo.The first cha ...What the Heck is Branding and Why Should I Care? There's been a lot of buzz lately about branding. But what exactly is it, and who needs to do it? Simply put, a brand is what makes your business uniquely YOU! It's the way you present your business and how the world perceives it. And, importantly, it's the way your clients remember you when it comes time to make another purchase. Branding encom ...Going Loco for Logos You have just opened your business and are about to place your first ad in the newspaper or Yellow Pages. The rep asks you if you have a logo. Gulp. A logo? You panic and realize you have to have one and fast. After all, every business has a logo and look how successful they have become. Check out Coke, Microsoft, Honda, Wal-Mart, and the list g ...Branding Marketing Plan Corporate Branding As Branding and marketing professionals, we have an in-depth understanding of the importance of a marketing plan. However, not everyone recognizes the benefits of investing in a strategic marketing plan prior to launching strategies and tactics that seem intuitive at the time. The following few paragraphs attempt to impart our understanding of a ...Building a Strong Brand Marriage If brands are about relationships, why not build a strong brand marriage?I’m not suggesting you actually walk down the aisle with your customers. But maybe the time has come to look at brand relationships in a different way?We all know that the best brands make strong emotional connections with their customers. Recent research su ...What Designers Do and Don't Want You to Know About Deadlines Deadlines are a part of business, particularly in the business of design. Clients often approach me in the 11th hour, expecting a miracle. The truth is, while accomplished designers can create extraordinary artwork in a shorten amount of time, it's more advantageous for business owners to afford the designer ample time to go through her/his crea ...When Search Engine Marketing and Trademarks Collide In the world of marketing, branding issues are always an important part of any campaign. Companies work hard for their name to be recognized as a quality organization and a leader in their field. Companies will defend any action they see as a negative to their brand. They do not want unauthorized third parties to advertise their products, bec ...Baileys Baileys is one of the most popular brands existing. Not many people know that the same company produces Baileys Cream, Guiness and Smirnoff. In this article we will take a closer look at the company and at the market it operates in.1.1 Baileys Irish Cream is one of the brands owned by Diageo PLC. Diageo PLC is the parent organisation of B ...
|